Welcome to Sweet Tooth Baking Company
Where Quality & Taste are Never Compromised for Beauty
Welcome to Sweet Tooth Baking Company
Where Quality & Taste are Never Compromised for Beauty
About Sweet Tooth Baking Co
Our Expertise
Quality Ingredients
Our Philosophy
Our expert baker and decorator has years of experience creating stunning wedding cakes. We are constantly learning and pushing ourselves to create new and innovative designs. Whether you want a traditional tiered cake or something more modern, we have the skills and expertise to bring your vision to life.
Our Philosophy
Quality Ingredients
Our Philosophy
At Sweet Tooth Baking Company, we believe that every wedding deserves a stunning cake that reflects the couple's unique love story. Your cake should mirror the joy and love you have for each other on this momentous day. Our goal is to create a cake that is not only elegant but is equally as delicious. We take great care to ensure that every cake is made with love and attention to detail.
Quality Ingredients
Quality Ingredients
Quality Ingredients
Sweet Tooth Baking Company prioritizes quality and flavor to create unforgettable experiences for you and your guests. We use only the finest ingredients to create our wedding cakes, ensuring that each bite is a delightful experience. From home-made vanilla extract, to fresh local fruits and organic ingredients, quality is at the heart of everything we do.
Testimonials
Kelly + Jeremy
Cambria + Brian
Kelly + Jeremy
I started following Grace & Sweet Tooth Baking on Instagram. I could tell that Grace went above & beyond with her cakes & cupcakes. Where other profiles will post a picture, Grace shares her entire process. It is easy to see that all of her cakes are unique to her clients, beautiful, & definitely fun. My wedding of 100 people utilized 6 different vendors. Of those, Grace was the easiest, most communicable, & most client-centered. She was open to any & all suggestions & genuinely listened & responded to what my hopes for my wedding cake were. Grace was transparent with pricing & logistics, something that I was so grateful for when other wedding vendors seemed like they were always surprising me with something else to add to their cost. Not only was Grace helpful with planning my cake, the colors, the vibe, & my favorite part- the flavors, but she was so supportive in the whole wedding process offering support & suggestions for things like music & vendor coordination. She truly takes pride in her product & delivers it with a service that I have never seen before after working weddings for 9 years. As a sober bride, I literally looked forward to eating cake the most the evening of my wedding. Not only was it beautiful but it was absolutely delicious! Writing this review makes my mouth water all over again, the cakes were so delicious & moist & such good flavor. Overall, Grace is everything I could’ve dreamt of for working with (& what I wish it was like working with other vendors!). Not only is she a dream to work with, but damn, she delivers an amazing product that is both gorgeous but also so tasty. Going with Sweet Tooth Baking will not let you down as you support a small, woman-owned business that puts your needs at the absolute front of it all, whether it is your wedding day or your nephew's birthday. Thank you so much, Grace!
Kelly Bartlett, 2024 Bride
Taylor + Lucas
Cambria + Brian
Kelly + Jeremy
We recently had the pleasure of working with Gracie at Sweet Tooth Baking Company for my wedding cake, and I cannot express how thrilled we were with the entire experience! From our first meeting with her, it was clear that she was dedicated to creating something truly special for us.
The customization options were fantastic, and Gracie took the time to understand our vision and how important the cake was to us. The cake not only looked stunning, but it also tasted absolutely divine. Each layer was a delightful blend of flavors that left our guests raving about it long after the reception. She worked with our budget and made the most incredible cake/cupcake set up I could’ve imagined.
We received so many compliments from our friends and family, with many claiming it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted! Gracie truly exceeded our expectations, making our special day even sweeter. I wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone looking for a talented and creative baker who will go above and beyond to make your dream cake a reality. Thank you, Gracie for being such an integral part of our celebration!
Taylor Kwoka - 2024 Bride
Cambria + Brian
Cambria + Brian
Cambria + Brian
While everyone knows that wedding planning is difficult, choosing Gracie for our cake was not! We struggled to find someone who could do a Gluten Free cake, as we have family members who are severely allergic. Gracie was super helpful and so responsive to all my questions, it felt amazing to be so taken care of!
Usually we have to accept semi okay gluten free products because that’s all that’s offered, but I didn’t want that for my wedding. So glad we went with Gracie because this was hands down one of the best cakes I’ve ever had gluten or not!
Highly recommend the chocolate cake with espresso rum filling! The chocolate was so decadent and I could eat an entire bowl of that espresso rum filling!
Cambria Duck, 2024 Bride
Bailey + Justin
Vendors Working Together
Cambria + Brian
My Dream Cake!
Gracie really made my cake dreams come true and was great to work with throughout the entire process. She took the time to understand what I really wanted and executed it perfectly. From building the cake to delivering it to the venue Gracie kept us in the loop and updated the entire time. Not only did our cake look amazing but it was literally one of the best cakes I have ever tasted and all of our guests were so impressed with the flavors (which there was a huge selection of). My personal favorite was the cookies and cream cake! Gracie is a true professional and I couldn't recommend anyone better to trust your special day to!
Bailey Weiss Hulsey, 2022 Bride
Vendors Working Together
Vendors Working Together
Vendors Working Together
You cannot go wrong hiring Sweet Tooth Baking Co. Often, when choosing desserts for a big event (especially for a wedding) you are trading taste for design. Not so with Grace!!
Grace somehow manages to make the most stunning cakes that taste just as good as they look. As a wedding coordinator, I work with a lot of wonderful vendors, but sometimes I work with a vendor that just stands out in my mind. Sweet Tooth Baking Co. is one such example! Grace is amazing at what she does, as well as being the kindest person. She is professional, knowledgeable in her field, and truly goes the extra mile for her clients. If I had it my way, every couple I work with would hire Sweet Tooth Baking Co.! Hiring Grace for your wedding or event will be one less thing you’ll have to worry about! Trust me on this one: she’s the best!!
Stephanie Grigson, Wedding Coordinator for Ideal Weddings
Rob + Orlee
Vendors Working Together
Vendors Working Together
Grace is the best. She makes a stressful decision of choosing a cake fun! Grace is so knowledgeable about options and if you are lost, like we were, can recommend what she thinks will work best. The cakes are not only perfect and gorgeous, but they taste incredible. We ate the top (after freezing, thawing) on our first anniversary and it was just as good, maybe even better? She asks the right questions and figures out the details that matter with the couple or the planner so that the cake will arrive in perfect shape, whatever the weather may hold. And she's just a fun person to work with. Can't recommend her enough!
Orlee Mainmon, 2022 Bride
Stephanie + Sean
Stephanie + Sean
Stephanie + Sean
5/5 STARS!
Could not recommend enough. Gracie goes above and beyond to make your day extra special. Our wedding cake was absolutely perfect. Every detail was done with such care and talent. On top of that, it was easily the best tasting cake I’ve ever eaten. Every single person had nothing but amazing things to say, it was an absolute hit.
Stephanie Allmon, 2020 Bride
Michelle + Evan
Stephanie + Sean
Stephanie + Sean
My husband and I eloped in August and Grace baked us a “happily ever after party” cake for a large celebration with family. She asked the right questions about size, flavors, and designs, and she FAR exceeded any cake expectations we had! She is a baker who truly cares. I THINK her secret ingredient is love, but she won’t tell us. After our initial consult, Grace stayed in constant contact with us, sending us all kinds of designs and decorations. I truly felt like I could have had her make anything I wanted and she would have delivered on my requests. She used a fern style stencil on the buttercream and it left an absolutely stunning texture on our cake. She took it a step further and added the same kind of flowers that were in my wedding bouquet to decorate the cake. Beautiful looks aside, there was not a single person at our party who didn’t finish their slice. I would highly recommend Sweet Tooth Baking Co for any event you have! Thank you Grace for making the cake of our dreams!
-Michelle Matic, 2024 Bride
Haley + Noah
Stephanie + Sean
Haley + Noah
Gracie at sweet tooth baking company made all my wedding dreams come true. I grew up in Youngstown, OH where cookie tables at events became tradition. This tradition has been important to my family in many ways, we have lists of family recipes we all make. Unfortunately, the event space we booked did not allow us to make our own cookies, they needed to be made my a licensed facility. Gracie stepped right up! We worked closely up to the big day. I shared the importance of the table & we discussed my family recipes. Gracie duplicated everything to perfection. My Italian aunt said “you can make our family recipes any time you want.” To make the night even better, she embodied our personalities in the cutest cake. I recommend Sweet Tooth baking company for ALL your baking needs.
Haley Pinochi, 2024 Bride
Here you'll find our menu and price guide. All cakes are priced for basic decoration, 2 layers of cake with one filling and vanilla swiss buttercream. Wedding cakes that require height or decorations will be an additional charge.
We are not limited to cakes or cupcakes, but have a very broad portfolio of baking. Please reach out with any further questions or inquiries.
For Zelle Please Reach Out to Us
Online Payments
If you have received an invoice and are prepared to place your order and accept our terms of service, kindly submit your 50% deposit here to secure your date.
Wedding orders require 50% deposit upon placing the order, & minimum 30 days prior to your event. In addition full payment is required at the 30 day mark.